Whistler’s Western Volume 2- Penn Central


Producer: Steve Bransfield & Phil Johnson

Timeframe: 1970s

Locations: Post Rd. NY to N. Grafton, MA

Length: 54 minutes

Source: Bruce Malone

The Boston & Albany, in Penn Central black. Whistler’s Western? Are you serious? Nonsense! Who cares. Just another route, to the Penn Central. Ignore the goofy title. If you enjoy the black diesels and a green caboose. Hop aboard!

Filmed in full color. Unrestored, but looks fine. Balanced presentation. Nothing weird. Just do not expect modern, crystal clarity.


Imagery ranges around very good overall. Variable, with the sometimes grainy and murky backgrounds. Can be focus issues.


Audio is dubbed. Some scenes work better than others. Levels are even.

No Chapter Menu is included.


Ted Daluku is the reliable narrator. Clear and professional. Fine job!

In the above scene. Action at Chester. Check all that power. Power balance move.


A good script. This time, a little thin on some details. They mention to assume, the viewer has digested the information from the first volume. (3263 is a GP40)


A rudimentary map early on. Once, and a minimal effort. Location references are verbal throughout.

Starting point is Western end of the B&A line. It is at Post Road Crossing , New York.

Never heard of that place. Alright then…We are moving Eastbound, most of the time.


This volume is focused on trainwatching. Nothing wrong with that. Pacing is the key.

An error or two in the script. Nearly all shows contain errors. If memory serves. This scene called for ,”An all GE lineup”. Not critical. In fact, if the viewer should yawn or sip a beverage. They miss the mistake. Carry on!


The action is tightly constructed. Quickly, moving from one train, onto the following one. Cinematography is excellent, by Bruce Malone!


The Washington Cut. A deep rock cut, provides a different viewing angle. Looks like a GE U-33C in the lead.


Penn Central freight trains roll by the camera in an endless supply.


Big General Electrics share duties with EMD GP40 and GP38 units. PC # 2910 is a GE U33B.


Amtrak Lake Shores Limited.


Plenty of former New York Central cabooses, still service the line. Model railroaders will find a good supply of rolling stock.


Interchange, with a Grand Trunk GP9, on the lead. Central Vermont train. Palmer location.


An SW1500 also at Palmer. A branchline here. The transfer caboose was handy. Long platforms good for switching cars. They were used on many railroads. These were former New York Central. Some lasted into Conrail.


Piggyback trains as they were called back in the day. A caboose on every one!


Extra 8130 slows for orders. (FYI… 8130 is a GP38-2, your welcome)! Bruce Malone was a Penn Central employee.


Train moves through the makeshift station. This is near the old Westfield Station.


The Conductor grabs the flimsies. Maybe Bruce knew these guys. He is really close.


Extra 6523 is shot from above, at Charleton. An Erie Lackawanna GE, is third in this lash-up.


An easily recognizable caboose. Class N5C. A former Pennsylvania porthole window. These lasted into the Conrail years.

Sharp eyes, will find a little bit of: CR re-lettered cabooses and a boxcar. I could have shown them. Nah! You can hunt them. More fun that way.

Whistler’s Western Volume 2- Penn Central Black

This show does perform, with the constant parade of trains. Penn Central fans will enjoy it the most.

If it grabs you. You know. That’s the ticket.

Rating: 4 Stars

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s