Chicago Odyssey Volume 2

Chicago Odyssey Volume 2

Green Frog Productions

Format: 2 DVD set

Length: 2 1/2 hours

Time period: 1962- 1973

Locations: Chicago area

Source: Emery Gulash (16mm)

This program picks up where Volume One left off. Emery Gulash and his cameras are at Chicago. The later time period offers up a timeframe that many will remember. If the 1950′s is before your time, by a decade or so, this will be the one for you.

Emery Gulash is an original master of train videos. He was out doing these splendid films at just the right time. Who knew that so much of all this, would pass into history? Maybe Emery knew, having witnessed the disappearance of steam. An extremely well-traveled man. Here we visit Chicago in multiple trips. Various years have us see some of the changes in the ten years of railfanning at this mega hub of United States railroading.

These are top shelf films from this master cinematographer. As usual, Green Frog has excellent production values. A fine script, good edits, and lovely film.

By the way, there are quite a few Odyssey titles that are reviewed on ATVR. Fine series!

Bob Carrera’s narration is informative and interesting. Natural sounds are included at the right moments. A few missed identifications on locomotives. Only noticeable to those that are aware.

A chapter menu divides by years and locations.

Film quality is superb. Besides the clarity of the 16mm film, it is all color. The colors are well balanced. The images are very clean. Excellent audio compliments the film.

Many of the classic roads that served Chicago are presented in this volume. ATSF, BN, CB&Q, CNW, GM&O, IC, Rock, Milw, GTW, C&O, B&O, EJ&E, PC, ICG, Soo, IHB, South Shore, and Amtrak. Others get cameos like Southern Pacific and Union Pacific.

Let’s begin with the first disc highlights of this 2 DVD set.

April ’62 begins with Milwaukee Road and Chicago and Nortwestern action at Noble Street Tower. Some old ’400′ CNW equipment is seen. The CNW commuters looked about  the same, up until the early 1980′s. At Deerfield, Milwaukee Road freight with orange/maroon F-units and an RS-3. Rondout Jct., with Milwaukee Road and EJ&E centercabs.

January of 1963 and zero degrees show why Chicago is too cold in the winter.

March of ’67 at Joliet. GM&O Abraham Lincoln and a Santa Fe freight on a cold, March day. GM&O, The Limited climbs a grade.

May ’70 at Morton Grove. Milwaukee passenger trains. This part drags the show. CNW at Wilmette. More passengers and double deckers. Repetitive.

Milwaukee Road F7′s in orange/ black lead a thru freight. A local with an SW7 moves next.

Burlington Route passengers are now BN, but you can’t tell. A BN painted E8 leads a mixed consist, at Hinckley. More BN freight trains, in various paint are viewed.

At Lemont, the GM&O with the Abraham Lincoln rolls thru town. The stone station dates from 1853.

Grand Trunk Western puts on a parade at Oak Glen. Old green/ gold runs with newer black/ orange. Both resemble owner Canadian National paint schemes.

Blue Island is a very busy crossing. Much action is seen here. Indiana Harbor Belt, Grand Trunk, and B&O. Rock Island shows up too. A Milwaukee Road freight, a Penn Central train and a couple of B&O switcher transfers. Lots of first generation power. Classic freight cars complete the satisfying chapter.

Back to Gulf, Mobile & Ohio in Lemont.

Burlington Northern is still a new entity. The renumbered units are still in original owner paint.

Emery frequented Lemont. Santa Fe was another railroad that ran through Lemont. Emery picks up some warbonnet F’s on a passenger train. Joliet was further out on that line. Emery shoots plenty of action at Joliet. He gets the El Capitain behind some FP45 units. The San Francisco Chief arrives behind F7′s. A trio GP20′s were on point of a freight. A classic Santa Fe caboose brings up the markers. There is more at Lemont. Check the ATSF train sattion there.

Willow Springs is a short sequence. This was the next town up the line from Lemont. Five GP20′s on a manifest freight train. Super Chief behind FP 45′s. Yes, they are warbonnets.

Illinois Central green electric cars look like antiques! Illinois Central provides a surprise, with a freight. A South Shore electric crosses this Kensington Junction. Another surprise is an IC E8A, lettered for Central of Georgia, with a passenger train.

Griffith Jct. has some more action. Grand Trunk trains and C&O GP9′s on a freight.

Amtrak in Transition shows the ragtag collection off cast off equipment in early times. Back to ICRR in Chicago. New and old electrics. Passenger cars, and freight. Good chapter.

That concludes this great first disc. This is the best one in the set, by a longshot!

Here is most of disc 2…… Passenger trains.

A long segment of the old CTA on the Dan Ryan….yawn.                                                  Soo Line has a single freight train, with a single locomotive.                                             Soo Line has one more freight, much later.

Illinois Central Gulf in ’73, provides some badly needed balance here. Even the vintage TOFC train looks great. SW’s pull a transfer, with a red ICRR side door caboose.

Burlington Northern at busy Clyde Yard, not Cicero yard with a single freight.

Back to the passenger trains around the city. Some fine shots, Rock Island, Penn Central E8′s with refurbished Amtrak cars. A few impressive bridges add interest on this otherwise, excessive passenger segment. Light engine moves are sweet!

While the first disc is well balanced with some passenger emphasis. The second disc almost lacks freight entirely! Too bad. The freights in those years are real classics.

The breakdown on this set. Great first disc. The second disc is much too heavy on the Amtrak transition. A rather repetitious second disc. Still, it is all Emery Gulash.

Rating: 4 Stars

Empire Of The North: The Forming Of The Burlington Northern

Empire Of The North: The Forming Of The Burlington Northern (D-121)

Charles Smiley Presents

Format: DVD

Length: 1 hour 31 minutes

Time Period: Early History to 1970′s. Plus some post- merger to BNSF 2001.

Locations: Systemwide

Sources: Many, 15 film credits alone. Charles Smiley has a video credit. Still photos and illustrations.

MSRP: 29.50

A very comprehensive program by the multi- talented Charles Smiley. The Burlington Northern merger of 1970 was a huge merger. Major railroads combined: Great Northern, Burlington Route, Northern Pacific and Spokane, Portland and Seattle into the BN. Subsidiary lines such as: Colorado and Southern, Fort Worth and Denver are included.

Historical aspects and the focus on past rail barons such as: James Hill of Great Northern and E.H. Harriman of Union Pacific make a worthy basis for this story. James Hill became known as The Empire Builder. Teddy Roosevelt becomes a trust buster. The remaining merger roads are effectively covered as well.

The high-flying Charles Smiley is a generous host. There are many assorted views, and often relevant talks about other railroads. EL, GM&O, DRGW,  PRR, WP, MILW, ROCK, UP, SP, ATSF and more! As I was in close proximity to GM&O circa 1972 on, that segment really was unexpected on a BN show. Icing on the cake.

Some people correctly make note of overlapping footage in some CSP shows. This is needed to ‘tell the story’ of a given railroad. As the prototypes connect and interact, so do the stories. As Milwaukee Road interaction is offered, why not see Milwaukee Road?     Any overlaps are small portions of the lengthy programs. As the digitally restored and enhanced films are of very high quality, the additional scenes are fine.

There is a chapter menu on this DVD. All Charles Smiley releases are manufactured  glass mastered DVD’s. Highest quality and better durability are another bonus of CSP.

Charles continues with his winning style of presentation. Much like a PBS broadcast quality program, these shows are some of the best available train videos. His thorough,  detailed discussions provide seemingly limitless information. Inside information often brings points to light of how railroading has evolved. Fascinating!

Subject features are in a plentiful supply. Viewers will come away with historical knowledge of wide-ranging subjects such as: Panama Canal, Ralph Budd, Western Pacific’s Inside Gateway, CB&Q Zephyr, World War 2, California Zephyr, Baldwin, Alco, and plenty of additional.

The cornucopia of trains is nearly overwhelming. You will need multiple sessions of viewing this show, to take it all in. All digitally re-mastered and painstakingly added natural sounds make for great sequences. Mainly color with limited black and white footage.

All the diesel makers that supplied the Hill Lines are discussed and on parade here. Some of the original paint schemes from the 2000 BN locos, are seen in early BN renumbering for ICC compliance. Watch for the small lettered/ renumbered units.The BN roster was vast, and there is just so much to see. Color film from the 1950′s to 1970′s, is very satisfying. Many rare locomotives are viewed on ‘in service sequences’ in all types of terrain. There are terrific mountain railroad shots.

Custom made maps are always a highlight bonus on a CSP release. This show provides looks at system maps for multiple railroads. They are shown as needed, to enhance a discussion. Local maps are used to facilitate understanding of a specific area.  Kudos!

Chicago, Burlington & Quincy has nice coverage. Ralph Budd and his successful introduction of the speedy Zephyr rolls film back to 1934.  An array of vintage film goes right along with the story of the CB&Q. Stainless steel Zephyrs, Black & Gray ‘Everywhere West’ and later Chinese Red color schemes are … everywhere!

Great Northern provides some spectacular backdrops for those trains. James Hill is shown as the force behind the creation of Great Northern and the mountainous crossing   of the line across the wilderness. GN Alcos are seen in the 1950′s- 1960′s. Main supply from EMD were the bulk of the Hill Lines.

Northern Pacific has its share of time too. Big steam and first generation diesels abound. The North Coast Limited was the centerpiece of NP passenger service. Many NP shots.

NP leads a feature set on steam locomotives. Much color footage and a transition to a CB&Q steam sequence with extra screen time.

Spokane, Portland and Seattle is the least known merger partner. It contributed many Alco locomotives to BN.

Cascade Green, Black and White of the Burlington Northern are a change from the complex earlier paint schemes of the old roads. First generation power is abundant. Newer locomotives and repainted cars spread the new BN image.

The special feature on Western Pacific’s Inside Gateway is a movie within this movie. Keddie Wye and area are visited. Old, smoke belching Alcos, mix with 1st and 2nd generation EMD power. Much scenic footage and raw diesel power to savor. Close-up views put you trackside, in this mountainous region. WP plus BN locomotives pulling vintage freight trains.

One late segment showcases Chicago area railroads in the early 1970′s. Packs a punch.

Fast forward to 2001, he provides a quick update to the BN story,and BNSF, in the contemporary era.

Classic freight cars and named passenger trains are the right ingredients for excellent trainwatching. Rare Alcos lead the way on some trains.This is a railfan’s delight!

This program is one that is hard to step away from. You never know what is coming next! If you only could own a single BN train video, this is the one to have.

A fine film for the entire family. Any train enthusiast will love this show. Unbelievably superior film about Burlington Northern. Nothing has been overlooked. Complete.

Also, there are some fine extended previews of other Charles Smiley Presents programs.

Empire Of The North: The Forming of the Burlington Northern  is an instant classic.           It is an instant favorite too!

Rating: 5 Stars

Extreme Trains- Overnight Traveler- History Channel

Overnight Traveler- Extreme Trains

History Channel

Format: DVD

 Length: 55 minutes

Locations: Chicago mainline to Seattle

Source: Extreme Trains- Season One

Host: Matt Brown

The story of  Amtrak’s Empire Builder. The modern version of former Great Northern premier passenger train.

Multi faceted look at the Amtrak train: the equipment, employees, people and the trip.

A fast-moving and varied presentation.  Historical aspects and modern operation are both well researched. This is very informative and fascinating journey, over a classic train trip. Rich in history with some great scenic vistas!

Favorite sequence is Matt on a snowmobile, on the original (abandoned) Cascade Tunnel line.

A long feature on Cascade Tunnel is a highpoint.

A nicely done program. Good for the whole family. The woman should like this show too.

Rating: 4 Stars

Chicago Odyssey Volume 1

Chicago Odyssey Volume 1

Green Frog Productions

Format: 2 DVD set   Length: 2 Hours

Time Period: 1954-1969         

Locations: Willow Springs, LaGrange, Naperville, Homewood, Joliet, Griffith

Source: Emery Gulash

 This set covers Chicago are in the 1950′s – 1960′s. The many railroads and locations give a good overview of the Chicago area. The combination of Green Frog and Emery Gulash is usually, a good match of filming, and production. Does it work on this release?

The era that is portrayed had a desired element for railfans, then and now. Many roads ran many more trains! A balanced mixture of freight and passenger trains. There is such a myriad of trains, it’s difficult to condense it down in a review. We’ll get it done.

  The railroads include: ATSF, CB&Q, NP, GN, IC, RI, CNW, MILW, GM&O, GT,                    NW, C&O, EL.

  The power is as varied as the roads themselves. An abundance of 1st generation Electromotive, with some new 2nd generation on mainline freight trains. Fast freights behind GP20 and GP30 matched sets are a sight! Alcos are present, in a small percentage. Watch for GE-U25B’s. Some steam is also viewed. Electrified Illinois Central and a North Shore segment. Nice to see, all the original paint schemes, along with some updated ones. I enjoyed the Grand Trunk, original and new in particular.

 Burlington Route gets the largest share of time. Less photographed lines such as Monon, Chicago & Eastern Illinois, EJ&E are also shown.

Highlights: CB&Q-Afternoon at Naperville, Illinois Central at Kankakee, Grand Trunk at Griffith Crossing, Union Station, Santa Fe at Willow Springs

 There is a CB&Q steam fan trip near the beginning, and another shows up as a distraction later on. As I have said before; these bog down the story, in this case, the daily action of Chicago. This footage should be at the end, as a bonus. The images are fine, but I want those early diesels and classic boxcars. The fast paced action of the show, gets derailed as we chase this thing halfway across the state. A GTW special and more. Specials…..

Quality is first-rate. The sound is excellent and is the live sound type. Dolby Digital Stereo. The picture is crisp. Colors are bright and it all…looks right. That 16mm film has never looked better, then in the DVD version. I had the vhs tapes for years and upgraded to this dvd version. Narration is descriptive, but sits back enough to let the sounds come through.

 This is one of my longtime Green Frog/ Gulash favourites. I have to bring the ‘specials’ up as a reviewer. The rest of the program is perfect. There is such a wealth of great trainwatching in this set. Highly recommended for veteran and new railfans. An outstanding overview of the Chicago mecca, at its peak!

Rating 4 1/2 Stars 

                                                                                                                                                       

 

Mainline USA

My model. Artwork not found.

 Mainline USA

Association of American Railroads

Format: VHS    Length: 20 minutes

Time Period: 1957

Locations: USA.. of course!

Source: Edwin Olsen

Promotional tape produced by the AAR in 1957. All color film. An early documentary style. This looks very good, considering the time it was made. The show doesn’t have the amount of train action, that you would expect. The main focus, is how the railroad serves the nation and you. It is very dated, as expected. These old films weren’t made for the railfan. I don’t believe, the word railfan, even existed in 1957. I wouldn’t be surprised, to see Lassie run across the screen, and rescue a cat from an oncoming train. That would beat; looking at loaves of bread, or a field of wheat, or the truck that hauls the bread, wheat.. whatever. It’s not real corny, like some others of the time.

 What about the trains? They are in the mix of the nation at work. Seen whizzing by: Pennsylvania Baldwin Sharks, Northern Pacific F7′s, Santa Fe F3′s, Great Northern FT’s, Southern Pacific F7′s. More Alco’s and Baldwins , but little more then glances. Passenger trains aka.. Modern Streamliners with: E8/E class, action from Rock Island, Lackawanna, Burlington Route, Chicago and Northwestern. Nice shots aboard a modern domeliner equipped train. What ? No Cary Grant? Not a complaint, but a compliment to the film quality.

 American Industry gets it’s plugs too. Coal, copper, iron, cotton , cows all are here. Notice the smokestacks, from a time when America was a manufacturer to the world. All those grimy smokestacks meant … jobs.

 The railroad segments included are the best part of the program. I like the hump yard visit. Love those steam era boxcars! Looks like it’s out west, maybe an ATSF modern facility. Various freight operations, icing reefers, early piggyback- with Illinois Central.. and surprise for ’57.. COFC on Rock Island!

 Is your favourite railroad within the program? They do show many roads. Some others are: Wabash, Southern Pacific, Frisco, L&N, New York Central, Santa Fe Warbonnet, and yes… they make you wait for it….. Union Pacific.

 So, is this worth acquiring? Yes, if you enjoy 1950′s railroading, there are some things to see. It is decent narration, and music that is scored to the film. No natural sound. It looks good and really captures the time it was filmed. Only 20 minutes long, and it doesn’t really have many trains, until the second half. Still.. I would like to see those Rock Island containers again .

 Rating 3 Stars